[Gluster-users] [ovirt-users] Replicated Glusterfs on top of ZFS

[Arman Khalatyan]

On Fri, Mar 3, 2017 at 7:00 PM, Darrell Budic <budic at onholyground.com>
wrote:

> Why are you using an arbitrator if all your HW configs are identical? I’d
> use a true replica 3 in this case.
>
>
This was just GIU suggestion when I was creating the cluster it was asking
for the 3 Hosts , I did not knew even that an Arbiter does not keep the
data.
I am not so sure if I can change the type of the glusterfs to triplicated
one in the running system, probably I need to destroy whole cluster.



> Also in my experience with gluster and vm hosting, the ZIL/slog degrades
> write performance unless it’s a truly dedicated disk. But I have 8 spinners
> backing my ZFS volumes, so trying to share a sata disk wasn’t a good zil.
> If yours is dedicated SAS, keep it, if it’s SATA, try testing without it.
>
>
We  have also several huge systems running with zfs quite successful over
the years. This was an idea to use zfs + glusterfs for the HA solutions.


> You don’t have compression enabled on your zfs volume, and I’d recommend
> enabling relatime on it. Depending on the amount of RAM in these boxes, you
> probably want to limit your zfs arc size to 8G or so (1/4 total ram or
> less). Gluster just works volumes hard during a rebuild, what’s the problem
> you’re seeing? If it’s affecting your VMs, using shading and tuning client
> & server threads can help avoid interruptions to your VMs while repairs are
> running. If you really need to limit it, you can use cgroups to keep it
> from hogging all the CPU, but it takes longer to heal, of course. There are
> a couple older posts and blogs about it, if you go back a while.
>

Yes I saw that glusterfs is CPU/RAM hugry!!! 99% of all 16 cores used just
for healing 500GB vm disks. It was taking almost infinity compare with nfs
storage (single disk+zfs ssd cache, for sure one get an penalty for the
HA:) )
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.gluster.org/pipermail/gluster-users/attachments/20170306/11a954e8/attachment.html>