[Gluster-devel] ping timeout

[Gordan Bobic]

Christopher Hawkins wrote:
> Correct me if I'm wrong, but something I would add to this debate is the type of split brain we are talking about. Glusterfs is quite different from GFS or OCFS2 in a key way, in that it is an overlay FS that uses locking to control who writes to the underlying files and how they do it.
> 
> It is not a cluster FS the way GFS is a cluster FS. For example if GFS has split brain, then fencing is the only thing preventing the complete destruction of all data as both nodes (assuming only two) write to the same disk at the same time and utterly destroy the filesystem. But glusterfs is passing writes to EXT3 or whatever, and at worst you get out of date files or lost updates, not a useless partition that used to have your data...
> 
> I think less stringent controls are appropriate in this case, and that GFS / OCFS2 are entirely different animals when it comes to how severe a split brain can be. They MUST be strict about fencing, but with Glusterfs you have a choice about how strict you need it to be. 

Not really. The only reason it is less bad is because the corruption 
will affect individual files, rather than the complete file system. 
Granted, this is much better than hosing the entire file system, but the 
fact remains that you get left with files that cannot be healed without 
manual intervention or explicitly specifying which node should win with 
the favorite-child option.

Gordan